| Name | Pos. | Ht. | Hometown | Previous School |
| Kyle Hanby | Tennis | 5-9 | Cass City, Mich. | Cass City |
| Mason Heller | Tennis | 6-0 | Leo, Ind. | Leo |
| Cedarville University at | 9 |
| Bethel | 0 |
| recap | |
| Manchester College at | 1 |
| Bethel | 8 |
| recap | |
| Bethel at | 3 |
| Indiana Institute of Technology | 6 |
| recap | |
| Bethel at | 6 |
| Cornerstone University | 3 |
| recap | |
| Bethel at | 5 |
| Defiance College | 4 |
| recap | |
| Bethel at | 6 |
| Calumet College of St. Joseph | 0 |
| recap | |
| Ohio Dominican College at | 8 |
| Bethel | 1 |
| recap | |
| Bethel at | 7 |
| Manchester College | 2 |
| recap | |
| Bethel at | 0 |
| Spring Arbor University | 5 |
| MCC Tournament | |
| recap | |
| Grace College at | 9 |
| Bethel | 0 |
| recap | |
| Bethel at | 1 |
| Spring Arbor University | 5 |
| Goshen College at | 5 |
| Bethel | 4 |